Middlebury College

Puccinelli was named to the Google Cloud College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA) Academic All-American At-Large First Team. She helped guide the Panthers to a single-season program-record 19 wins (19-3) in 2019 and the program's fourth-consecutive NCAA Semifinal appearance.

Puccinelli graduated with a 3.99 grade point average as a mathematics major at Middlebury and was the co-salutatorian of the 2019 graduating class. She was selected as the 2018 NCAA Elite 90 Award winner, presented to the student-athlete with the highest cumulative grade point average participating at the finals site for each of the NCAA's championships.

The two-time All-NESCAC honoree concluded 2018-19 with a team-high 21 wins (21-4) and a 14-2 mark in No. 3 position. The 2017 All-American wrapped up her career with 11 wins in her last 13 completed matches. Puccinelli finished with an impressive 69-24 record during her career individually as a Panther, ranking ninth in the ITA Northeast Region and 24th nationally at the end of her senior year.