4/24/05 - The Panther defense looked tough, las they led the team to a 14-3 win against Colby in a game played at Trinity. Middlebury led 5-0 after one quarter and took an 8-3 lead into the halftime break. Following a scoreless third quarter, the Panthers outscored the Mules 6-0 in the fourth quarter to seal the win.

Nick Bastis led the team with three goals in the game, while Jim Cabrera and J.P. Coviello added two goals apiece. Jonathan Sisto had a goal and three assists in the game to add to the offense. Alex Palmisano made six saves in goal.