The Middlebury men's ice hockey team had 16 members earn American Hockey Coaches Association Krampade/AHCA All-American Scholar accolades. A total of 664 athletes across Division II and III men's hockey were tabbed to the squad.

To earn the award, each athlete must obtain a grade point average of 3.75 or higher across the fall and spring semesters and appear in at least 40 percent of the team's contests.

Middlebury's honorees included Reece Brednich, John Burdett, Kam Carkner, Michael Fairfax, 

Kevin Golden, Andrew Heinze, Tucker Lamb and Jin Lee. Also earning the award are Jackson Morehouse, Matt Myers, Max Noll, Jake Oblak, Dante Palombo, Jack Silverman, Dimitri Tzaferis and Zach Whitehead.

Since the 2019-20 season, the Panthers have had 83 players recognized as All-American scholars.